Blog  /  What Happens During RFP Evaluation That Bidders Can't See?

What Happens During RFP Evaluation That Bidders Can't See?

Breezy Baldwin
Breezy Baldwin  ·  Updated November 17, 2026  ·  6 min read
image of brainstorm session with sticky notes (for a b2b saas)

During RFP evaluation, a panel scores your proposal against the published criteria, debates the scores, and weighs price behind a no-contact rule. Bidders can't see the scores, the debate, or what evaluators already believe about each firm. You can't enter that room, so your influence has to land before it closes or with deal-based marketing.

Who actually evaluates your proposal?

On large contracts, an evaluation committee scores your proposal, not a single buyer. Panels often mix procurement, technical reviewers, finance and operations, with executive leadership making or approving the final call. Each person reads your proposal through the lens of their own function.

You usually won't know who sits on the panel. Some of them may never have met your team. Your relationship with one champion doesn't guarantee the other evaluators see you the same way.

How are proposals scored behind closed doors?

Evaluators score each proposal against the criteria written into the RFP, and nothing else. US federal rules require agencies to assess proposals "solely on the factors and subfactors specified in the solicitation" (FAR 15.305). Agencies can use color ratings, adjectival ratings, numerical weights or a mix.

State processes look similar. North Dakota's RFP evaluators' guide describes a 100-point scale, with technical and cost scores added together. It tells evaluators they "MUST provide comments" to support each score.

The same guide describes two ways a committee reaches its result:

  • Group method: the committee meets and agrees on scores as a group.
  • Consolidation method: each member scores alone, and the procurement officer compiles the results.

It also calls it best practice for the committee not to know the price until initial technical scoring is complete. So your technical proposal is judged on its own before price enters the picture.

What bidders can't see during scoring

  • Individual scores and the written comments behind them.
  • The committee debate, which the North Dakota guide says can legitimately influence an evaluator’s judgment.
  • How technical merit gets traded off against price.
  • Outside information. Federal evaluators must consider past performance “information obtained from any other sources,” not only the references you list (FAR 15.305).

‍

What is the blackout period, and what does it prohibit?

A blackout period or bars bidders from discussing the procurement with anyone except a designated contact. It is also called a restricted period, evaluation period, silent period, or cone of silence.

New York's IT agency runs its restricted period from the start of the solicitation until award (NY ITS). During that time, only the designated contact can discuss the contract with businesses.

Federal rules set a similar line. "After release of the solicitation, the contracting officer must be the focal point of any exchange with potential offerors" (FAR 15.201).

North Dakota tells evaluators that direct communication with any offeror "is not appropriate" (North Dakota OMB). Any attempt by an offeror to reach an evaluator outside a committee session gets reported to the procurement officer.

Rules differ by agency, state and private buyer. Read the communication section of every solicitation and ask counsel when in doubt. Never contact evaluators about the bid during blackout, even informally.

Can clarifications or discussions fix a weak proposal?

No, clarifications are narrow and won't let you rework your proposal. Under federal rules, clarifications are "limited exchanges" used for things like minor clerical errors or the relevance of past performance (FAR 15.306).

Communications before the competitive range is set can't be used to cure deficiencies or materially change the proposal. With federal pursuits, government staff also can't favor one offeror over another during discussions. Your submitted document has to carry the case on its own, unless you use a service like Yappy.

Why do evaluators' existing perceptions matter so much?

Evaluators score against criteria, but they apply judgment, and judgment is shaped by what they already believe. North Dakota asks evaluators to "exercise your judgment" independently, while allowing committee debate to influence it (North Dakota OMB). Two evaluators can read the same section and score it differently.

Much of that belief forms without you in the room. Gartner research found B2B buyers "typically spend only 17% of their time meeting with potential suppliers" when considering a purchase (Gartner). The rest goes to research and internal deliberation you never see.

Dane Balle, Founder and CEO of Rotation Group, described the gap plainly. "We know we are the best choice, and we can explain why. We just couldn't get that message to the decision makers inside a pursuit who needed to hear it."

What can bidders legitimately do before the RFP is released?

Before release is when you have the most freedom to shape how buyers understand you. Federal agencies are "encouraged to promote early exchanges of information about future acquisitions" (FAR 15.201). Listed techniques include industry conferences, one-on-one meetings with potential offerors and RFIs.

State buyers are often open too. In a NASPO white paper survey, 88% of responding states reported no limits on talking with vendors before a formal solicitation (NASPO). Yet fewer than a third fully use the communication allowances they have.

Practical pre-RFP moves:

  1. Answer RFIs with substance. Your response can shape how the requirement gets written.
  2. Attend industry days and pre-solicitation conferences. Ask questions that show you understand the problem.
  3. Map the functions involved. Work out which parts of the organization will touch the decision, not just who your main contact is.
  4. Build perception across every function. Procurement, finance, operations and technical reviewers each care about different risks.
  5. Lock in win themes early. Messages repeated before the RFP feel familiar when evaluators meet them in your proposal.
  6. Plan to stay visible through evaluation. In commercial pursuits, line up a deal-based marketing program so the buying committee keeps hearing your story after submission.

How can you stay visible during evaluation without breaking contact rules?

Keep your general marketing running, as well as account-based or deal-based marketing, and keep anything about the pending procurement away from evaluators. Blackout rules govern contact about the procurement. They don't usually stop a firm from publishing case studies, thought leadership or brand content to its market.

The line can be thin, and some jurisdictions define prohibited contact broadly. Don't reference the open bid, its pricing or its evaluation in anything you publish. Check the solicitation and your counsel before running anything aimed at the buyer during a restricted period.

The safest approach is perception-driven marketing messaging, so evaluators know your story and capabilities, over an anonymized role-based ad delivery network (like LinkedIn).

What can you learn after the award?

After award, some of the black box opens. North Dakota warns evaluators that "any notations made on the evaluation worksheet will become public record after contract award" (North Dakota OMB). Request a debrief where one is offered, and ask for the evaluation record where public records law allows it.

Use what you learn to see where perceptions cost you points. Then start building them earlier on the next pursuit.

How Yappy helps

Yappy runs done-for-you executive ad programs around specific bids and deals. They put your message in front of every decision maker, and show you who's paying attention. Yappy's team builds the messaging and produces short, targeted videos that run on LinkedIn, industry sites and connected TV. The Yappy Platform shows which roles are engaging, including roles you didn't know were involved. Yappy doesn't write your proposal. Your team does. Yappy makes sure every decision maker evaluating it has already heard why you should win.

For Rotation Group, that meant a 6x win rate increase, 529 unique roles influenced and a $20M contract, the largest in its history. "Now we know our success rate will be around 80% on deals that we deploy Yappy on," said Dane Balle, CEO.

Final takeaway

During RFP evaluation, a multi-function panel scores your proposal against published criteria, debates the scores and weighs price, all behind a blackout rule you can't cross directly. Clarifications won't rescue a weak proposal, and evaluators' existing perceptions shape their judgment. Do the influence work before the RFP is released, and stay visible with account-based marketing without contacting evaluators about the bid.

Frequently asked questions

Can I contact an evaluator during the blackout period?

Not directly. During a blackout or restricted period, direct communication about the procurement goes through the designated contact only. Attempts to reach evaluators directly are typically reported to the procurement officer. Indirect communication like account-based advertising is acceptable in commercial pursuits.

Do evaluators know the price when they score the technical proposal?

Often not at first. North Dakota's evaluators' guide calls it best practice to withhold price until initial technical scoring is complete.

When is the best time to influence an RFP outcome?

Before the RFP is released, or before and during for commercial pursuits. Federal rules encourage early exchanges such as industry conferences, one-on-one meetings and RFIs, and most states allow pre-solicitation direct communication. Using anonymized account based advertising is a gray area in federal pursuits and acceptable in commercial.

Topics:  
Enterprise sales
Business Development

Share this post

Continue learning

Drive enterprise impact at scale

Subscribe for expert insights and industry trends. Stay ahead with actionable strategies for enterprise growth.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.